Published by The Second Opinion in the blog The Second Opinion's blog.
My original reaction to Rescue at Midnight Castle. Was I really THAT negative?
Yeah, this special could have been better had it not been rushed. Also, Megan and the ponies didn't thank the sea ponies the second time they helped. The rainbow is probably the dictionary definition of a rushed deus ex machina. For what it's worth though, there are some good ideas here, and this special has a decent atmosphere to boot. The sea pony scene kind of killed it, but it happens and then it's over, so meh.
I noticed something kind of interesting though. Megan's bow looks a lot like Applebloom's so I kind of wonder if that's supposed to be an Easter egg. I wouldn't be surprised. Firefly may have inspired Rainbow Dash but she's a different enough character that Rainbow isn't a straight up knockoff. For one, Firefly isn't necessarily a tomboy, she just happens to be one of the more courageous ponies.
She's definitely one of the more interesting characters in this special, especially among the ponies. Good thing she's never seen or mentioned again. Actually, while I went into this series expecting the presence of humans to be an issue for me, I have to say that proved to be far less problematic when the ponies themselves are probably the least interesting. Phasing out some of the more interesting characters before they can be properly developed probably doesn't help.
By the way, the order for this series is this special, Escape From Catrina, then the movie, and then the rest of the show.
Yeah, Escape From Catrina is the next thing we're going to be reviewing. After that though, we'll probably bring the series to a close with whatever we think the most appropriate 3rd story to review is.
Interesting point about Megan's bow. Apple Bloom's right in a position to take a more Megan-like role now too, so that might be something to watch for.
So far, as I said in the video, G1 is definitely better than you'd expect, but I don't know if that's necessarily something to recommend it for.
@The Second Opinion Well, I for one consider myself exclusively a G4 Brony, but I respect when someone says they're also a G1 Brony. Other shows...tend to fall short for one reason or another, but I do recommend checking them out if for no other reason than perspective.
G1 definitely has more good points than either Pony Tales or G3, but I think past gen MLP shows in general are something I'd only recommend to those who are really curious and have enough endurance to get through them. If nothing else they're definitely good conversation starters, but I prefer FiM for a variety of reasons and watching any of this just makes me wish I was watching FiM instead.
Separate names with a comma.