Should Found Footage Stop?

We see these films everywhere, but are they overstaying their welcome? Should Found Footage movies stop?


Check out this weeks charity – dupagepads.org here!

About Doug Walker

Creator of 5 Second Movies, Nostalgia Critic, Bum Reviews and more.

Leave a Reply

113 Comments on "Should Found Footage Stop?"

ThatManWithTheHeadband12
Guest
ThatManWithTheHeadband12

Found footage shouldn’t stop until you reach the end of the footage. That’s common sense, right?

RockmanX3
Guest

But there’s so much of it!!!

Backhand
Guest

Holy crap,this is a banal subject for an editorial.

Maybe he made the video in 2013(when it was relevant) and forgot to post it. Found footage is already dying down,every horror fan already had this conversation years ago,no exaggeration.

Goblin Scribe
Guest

As a non-horror fan, I’m finding this video interesting, but your response to this is not unlike my response to his attempts at “political correctness” examination. I’m guessing that’s just how it works: People who are already into it can tell he’s behind the curve, while those who aren’t are the ones who get value out of it.

mccuish
Guest

The Spanish horror movie REC also did a good job with the found camera footage style horror movie.

RockmanX3
Guest

Agreed, REC is one of the best examples of this genre.

Matt T. Dalldorf
Guest

“Agreed, REC is one of the best examples of this genre.”

And THAT’S why I’m not a fan.

ender140
Guest

Yep, this the only found footage movie I really liked.

Raven Minister
Guest

Yes. REC is amazing, and one of the few films out there that actually freaked me out.

agoodname
Guest

REC was great.

Rezro
Guest

Yeh, because it have good idea! It is about TV crew assisting rescue team caught in what no one could predict, not some lame ass people in lame ass scenario.

weldo8
Guest

Yes. They’re annoying. If something was done by Halloween: Resurrection, than it shouldn’t be repeated.

Deadpoolio
Guest

What the hell are you talking about? Halloween Resurrection WAS NOT done as a found footage film…I think you need to check your definition…REC YES, Blair Witch YES, Paranormal Craptivity YES….A “reality show” streaming LIVE on the internet on Halloween night IS NOT found footage, nobody came along and found Busta Rhymes video tapes hence the term FOUND footage

RockmanX3
Guest

lol! I used to call it Paranormal Asstivity myself.

weldo8
Guest

You’re right, but it has all the same elements and cliches.

Black INK.I.M
Guest

By that logic, shouldn’t all horor movies stop because they have the same tropes as some shitty horor movies?

MidnightScreeningsman2014
Guest
MidnightScreeningsman2014
Good editorial Doug I didn’t realize how much could be done with the found footage horror genre you opened my mind onto what can happen vs what can go bad. Also I heard that unfriended was a horrible movie from a lot of people on this site so to hear you not giving it crap feels refreshing and new. I also would like to see the paranormal activity franchise stop I hope they don’t make any others after this one(and if it bombs I’ll be even more happier). Also so glad this weeks featured producer is calluna she is my… Read more »
CoffeeBurps
Guest
My only comment here is that I’d have to disagree with what you said about Unfriended. The premise, of everything being shot from a computer screen, had SO MUCH potential but would probably be one of the hardest things to get right. And that movie did not get it right. The movie turned out to be one of the most boring things I’ve ever seen. I think that, had they stuck with video/voice chat, it would have been much better. But there just SO MUCH READING. It made me feel like I just spent $11 to go read a book… Read more »
Olddog
Guest

Here’s something I don’t understand. Why the cameras at all? The story could simply be told through a person’s perspective. This way the view could seem more human, and you’d be surprised how much emotion can be conveyed through motion. This is an idea often used in video games, even when the main character is totally silent, you can still get a rough idea what they’re feeling and what they’re like.

This is much more plausible than shoving cameras everywhere and FILMING everyone’s personal moments, and there won’t be any need for any silly distortion effects.

CainZeros
Guest

Because the conceit of “these are things this person saw that we somehow extracted from their brain” is a little harder to buy than “this is footage of this stuff happening that someone found”.

Olddog
Guest

That really doesn’t make any sense. Are you telling me that people see a regular non-point of view type movie and can only watch it by assuming it was recorded by multiple cameras conveniently placed at the scene? No one said it had to be information extracted from someone’s brain, it’s just told from a first person perspective. You know like a flashback or something. People don’t question those.

People use this idea in games all the time, and I even remember a TV show on Comedy Central called Secret Girlfriend that used the same idea.

kreative-kontrol
Guest
It’s really hard to do it for a prolonged time. You can’t change shots, it’s harder to cut, the angle is really wide and it’s harder to identify with someone you almost never see (only in mirrors and shit). It is very limiting. I’ve done it multiple times and it’s great for short form but already a challenge. Often in found footage films there are multiple cams so even the one with the cam in being filmed, you see their response. If not, the cameraman is not really the protaganist (like with REC for instance, the cameraman is a participant,… Read more »
Olddog
Guest

Doesn’t the fact that it’s a FOUND footage movie immediately dispel all mystery? They’re dead, otherwise it’s just a documentary.

Fran Ohmsford
Guest
For some reason there’s no reply button on Olddog’s reply to your post so I’ve had to click you Reply button: Olddog – This is my single biggest issue with Found Footage movies – I liked Cloverfield and I liked Paranormal Activity BUT they’re the exceptions. The original Paranormal Activity was a good movie but I’ve never watched ANY fo it’s sequels and have no intention of watching any of them! The reason being that despite the original being found footage the ending caught me offguard {I was new enough to the genre and the film didn’t hit you over… Read more »
Olddog
Guest

This idea can even make things scarier, since it’s easier to feel scared and alone, when crazy shit happens and no one will believe you when you HAVEN’T captured hours of footage of everything on high definition cameras.

nomad1112
Guest

Grace:the Possession. It did the perspective instead of camera thing.

Deans
Guest
Nice intro. Though I was more of an “Are You Afraid of the Dark?” fan than “Goosebumps” but that was great! Love the jacket too! I think there needs to be a distinction between “Found Footage” and “Mockumentary”. To me, found footage is like “Blair Witch Project” or “Paranormal Activity” where the movie is based on footage that was found during an investigation of sorts, which typically has that one big jump scare abrupt ending. But to me, “The Visit” for example is more of a mockumentary. The girl was making a movie on purpose and supposedly edited and put… Read more »
Danno Kane
Guest

the best found footage film I’ve seen in a long time is the movie VHS., the line between reality and fantasy blur so much in this film., I couldn’t tell the difference what was fake., vs what was real.,,.

BobLogical
Guest

Marbles Hornets.

RockmanX3
Guest

Great editorial as always Doug. Like mccuish said above, REC and Quarantine are good examples of found footage movies that I would highly recommend.

I never quite got into the Paranormal Activity films and my friends told me Blair Witch was the scariest thing ever, but it was more like 3 people yelling at each other in the forest.

Cloverfield was one of the first reviews I watched from the NC. Kinda nice seeing it in an NC again.

lisomaa
Guest

I would like to add “Trollhunter” to the list of good found footage films. It’s more of a dark fantasy and comedy film than a horror film, but nevertheless it’s a well done Norweigian film.

onenil
Guest

Trollhunter is fantastic! Highly recommended!

nomad1112
Guest

awesome movie

ErichoTTA
Guest

I personally thought the best found footage film was “Chronicle” which you featured here. That is simply an amazingly realistic film. “The Conjuring” was one of the best horror movies I’ve seen in recent films. I never got into the “Paranormal Activity” movies much. I’ve only seen the second one and it was just okay. Yep, I’m tired of them too.

Meamsosmart
Guest

Chronicle is my favorite too, most found footage isn’t really my thing, even the good ones, but i just really liked chronicle

leviadragon99
Guest

Yeah it irked me a little that he didn’t even mention Chronicle despite being happy to use footage from it. It did clever things, had a good story with interesting characters and used found-footage for a genre other than horror, so there was definitely stuff there to talk about there.

Spider-Matt
Guest

I watched The Visit with a friend of mine recently and we were the ONLY PEOPLE in the cinema. That added to the creep factor and we were constantly turning our heads thinking there were people behind us.

Professor von SCIENCE!!!
Guest
Professor von SCIENCE!!!

Man, I can sympathize with that. Good on Shamamalamasama for making a good movie again after all these years.

nomad1112
Guest

happened to me the first time I saw the first paranormal Activity….damn

Jasmine
Guest

The Blair Witch Project was actually inspired by a movie called “Cannibal Holocaust”, a movie that’s about a found footage that a company found and we watch the footage with them seeing the horror, gore, and crimes that the cameramen commit until their inevitable death by the cannibals.

GBD
Guest

That one’s only MOSTLY found footage. There’s a difference between mostly found footage and all found footage.

MountCDOSgamer
Guest

Still, there’s a lot of points to be made about how Cannibal Holocaust can be seen as the grandfather of found footage films.

GBD
Guest

Yeah, but I really wanted to do that Princess Bride reference. This was mosty just for that.

Isaac Smith
Guest

There’s due to be a found footage episode of Doctor Who this season, which i’m on the fence about.
On one hand, it’s a concept that could easily go very wrong and with Doctor Who’s recent track recore of quality, it’s not a promising outlook considering the rocky ground that this sub-genre is already treading on.
On the other hand, it’s never been done on the show before; and with the Doctor Who universe being full of monsters and… dare I say… paranormal activity, it might be an interesting framing device for something new.
I suppose we’ll have to wait and see.

Metalyger
Guest
I prefer found footage in underground horror movies, like when it’s a serial killer making a snuff film. If I found a VHS tape that had ghosts and zombies in it, I wouldn’t suddenly believe in ghosts and zombies. When I’m watching over an hour of hard violence and disturbing imagery, it’s very effective for me. Movies that show as much brutality as possible, that can still leave you with more than just gore, like piecing together the continuity in a movie that has no exposition. There’s also plenty of great moments in movies like August Underground where there’s a… Read more »
SpeedyEric
Guest
Cloverfield was the very first found footage movie I ever saw, and in the theater no less. I think that movie is awesome, and I proudly on a DVD copy of it in my collection. I year later, I finally saw the first found footage movie I’ve heard about, The Blair Witch Project, and it scared the living Hell out of me. And then the Paranormal Activity movies came along, and the ending to the first movie scared me so much, it left me speechless in a matter of minutes, and I put a cross on the nightstand of my… Read more »
Chuckward
Guest

He hasnt.

LKnives
Guest

Diary of the Dead was supposed to be found footage? It was shoot too well. I liked it, I took it as satire on this group of people who feel the need to film everything.

abort_user
Guest

“We’ve seen it so much we’re sick of it.” Don’t drag me into this! I didn’t see any of them! 😛

TheSKARD1
Guest

Should Found Footage Stop? Yes, please.

When I watch a scripted movie I want to believe it’s happening to those people. I don’t want to constantly question where the camera man is standing. Take the 1 season TV show Siberia for example. It was very inconsistent about whether the camera men were characters in the show or not. It’s very distracted knowing that part of the framing device is that this is being filmed, but it’s also scripted in a way that fails to answer how it’s being filmed.

MountCDOSgamer
Guest

One thing that should be said about found footage films is that it can make amateurish quality more forgivable. A personal favorite web series of mine, Marbel Hornets, was made by a group of people who couldn’t afford high-quality special effects, but the way it was filmed made it so real. Also, when found footage is uploaded online rather than made into a movie, it’s a lot easier to believe that it’s real.

kreative-kontrol
Guest

Yeah, that was a genius addition to the whole concept where it’s based on. From beginning to end, the whole world that’s created is online.

El Mariachi_47
Guest

Not really a fan of the genre/sub-genre, but the Norwegian film “Trollhunter” is pretty damn good. It wasn’t really a horror film, but was a damn good found footage film.

Roger C
Guest

No, they shouldn’t. Variety is the spice of life. No one is forced to go watch these movies.

Raven Minister
Guest

I wonder if Doug has seen Trolljegeren (Troll Hunter). It’s norwegian found footage film, which didn’t sound good as a premise, but IMO was executed surprisingly well.

Airam
Guest

Normally I hate found footage. I really do. But one film actually pulled it off for me without making me wanna strangle the creators: “As Above, So Below”. Maybe it’s not scary in the classical sense but it has an atmosphere throughout the movie and leaves you thinking afterwards, dissecting it because of all the references to Dante’s “Inferno”. It’s refreshing in the entire horror genre, not just found footage.

MonkeeJuice
Guest

The only ones I like are Blair Witch Project and Paranormal Activity.

OldManHermit
Guest
I understand why it’s divisive, but I think Blair Witch will always be my fav found footage film. It terrified me when I first saw it back in the day, and still holds up today imo. It understands subtlety, often times what you don’t see is far scarier than anything you do. This is a fact that’s lost on a lot of modern horror films. Also, for a slightly less subtle and more recent found footage horror film, check out Frankenstein’s Army. I watched it with my sister on a whim, and we were both pleasantly surprised. Without giving away… Read more »
ryuunahga
Guest

I’m surprised you didn’t mention Grave Encounters! Sure, the film isn’t the greatest, but it’s really creative, and the setting is really scary! Just don’t even bother with the sequel though. Also, I was so happy when I saw that Calluna was this weeks featured reviewer, because she instantly become one of my favorite reviewser! Not just on this site, but in general!

The Million Mask Man
Guest

Sorry? Blair Witch started the genre?
Two words, pal. CANNIBAL HOLOCAUST!

Matt T. Dalldorf
Guest

He did say there were probably others that he wasn’t aware of, so in all fairness, Doug was being pretty open about his ignorance.

The Million Mask Man
Guest

Well then consider this my way of informing him, because he should really check that one out!

firefly4f4
Guest
I’m sorry, Doug, but… UNFRIENDED WAS AWFUL, literally the only film I’ve ever watched that I’ve even CONSIDERED walking out of. I want to put that into perspective that this year alone I’ve suffered through Vacation, Fifty Shades of Grey, Pan, Jupiter Ascending, The Perfect Guy, The Gallows, Hot Pursuit, and Fant4stic. I also watched Battlefield: Earth and The Last Airbender in theatres. THIS is the film that made me consider walking out. The characters were horrible people, watching the computer screen and typing was boring as hell, reading the text was mindnumbing, it was predictable, not scary, and by… Read more »
Anon Tumahab
Guest
I personally think the reason Blair Witch got acclaim is because many people going to the theater didn’t realize it was fake. I had family members who didn’t myself. If you think it’s real, then…naturally, it’s terrifying. And unlike many other found-footage films, that one was not only “fresh” but was shot in a very realistic manner so it was convincing. Nowadays you know it’s all fake and everyone’s going to die at the end. I think the biggest mistake is big-budget found footage films like “Cloverfield” and “Chronicle”, because now the found-footage aspect is just a gimmick to try… Read more »
Matt T. Dalldorf
Guest

“What’s next? Creature from the Black Lagoon?”

Most likely, it’s one of four movies they haven’t remade yet. I don’t no about you, but, while I’m not a found-footage fan, I’m not nearly as tired to them as I am of fuckin’ remakes!

Anon Tumahab
Guest

…Although, in defense of the “found footage” genre, I definitely like it better than the other big modern sub-genre: “torture porn”.

1 2 3
wpDiscuz