An American Tail: Fievel Goes West – Nostalgia Critic

Everybody loves An American Tail, but it’s sequel had a lot of people scratching their heads. Can the Nostalgia Critic figure out why?

Support this week’s charity here!

About Doug Walker

Creator of 5 Second Movies, Nostalgia Critic, Bum Reviews and more.


  1. So…just quietly releasing a new Nostalgia Critic and still not addressing how horrible that second response was? I guess it’s probably better than whatever response video you were planning but yeesh. How long can one person keep their head in the sand?

  2. So, the emperor continues to fiddle as Rome burns.

  3. Doug, why?

  4. There have been already three weeks.

    Sooner or later you have to say something.

  5. This is getting kinda sad now

  6. Wait a minute.

    Didn’t you leave CA ?

    What’s the point of saying you workED at CA on your facebook if you still post video for CA ?????

  7. disembodiedvoiceofreason

    Doug doesn’t run the website, Mike Michaud does.

  8. and now there screenshots going on on internet showing doug quit channel awsome his work status said worked with channel awsome hpes not tue loved n.c shame he doesnt have the rights for it wouldnt mind a new channel with dough as nc

  9. – Critic the site is on fire!

    – No mother, its just the northern lights!

  10. Cinnamon Scudworth

    “Ha ha! I’ll never apologize! What can all you peasants do about me? My YT subscription numbers are still above a million! I’m too big to fail! I’m invincible! I’m gonna live forever! People remembah my name! No matter how loud you yell, I will always have fans! I’m above punishment! I can do anything! Suck it, losers! Anyway, how about that Fievel, huh?”

  11. “The review must go on (for today)! The review must go on (for today)!” I kid. Anyways, I haven’t seen either of these movies. Looks like I missed out on some uh… interesting times. ? However, if this is the last review, it was a pretty funny one! ?

  12. Great review as always, Doug. I’ve never seen this one but it looks promising enough. Might watch it for myself one day.

  13. I’m sure Doug recorded this episode before leaving the channel.
    Welp, I just hope this platform closes down and every victim just get at least an excuse.

    PS: You guys really covered up Jew Wario’s rape incidents? How low can you sink?

    • Did Doug officially announce he left? I know it’s on his FB but not sure if that’s not just something he’s had up for some time, usually they’d show time periods of when someone was employed there.

  14. Nice review Mr Nero.

  15. Rumor has it there’s only going to be one more NC after this, and Doug has changed his status as working with Channel Awesome to past tense on Facebook.

    Serves you damn right, Doug. I know a lot of people here are mad at Michaud, but I’m personally mad at YOU.

    YOU were in the chat with Michaud, Rob, and Holly when the discussion about JewWario’s sexual deviance and abuses came to light. You, a man who claims to stand against such disgusting acts by doing your charity shout outs, who preaches the better nature of man during the holidays, and who sought to make things better in the world through laughter and entertainment.

    And yet YOU helped to cover up a rapist, for the sake of saving face, for the sake of saving your brand, for the sake of MONEY.

    You, Doug Walker, have built up a standing against Hollywood corruption and greed, and yet YOU are part of that very same problem.

    You’re disgusting. I can’t believe I enjoyed your content and supported you.

    • I’m not mad at Doug, just dissapointed, I don’t think he’s “disgusting” at all, I feel bad for him considering he was between a rock and a hard place with Michaud owning the rights to NC and everything.

      Also we don’t know that Doug knew about JW.

      • You’re willing to believe that Michaud, Rob, AND Holly all knew about JewWario, but not Doug? Sounds convenient.

        Rape apologists get no sympathy from me, period.

        • Jalen Washington

          Hey bud, I’m not sure if you’ve noticed, but JewWario’s dead.
          You can pretend to be upset that you’ve just now figured out that a person you don’t even know raped some people (who, again, is dead now) all you want, but don’t get pissy with someone just because they don’t feel like slandering someone barely related to the issue in the first place.

          • Hey pally, I hope someone you love (or, forbid, you yourself) never gets raped and another excuses your attacker just like you did.

            Or, perhaps, to quote Channel “Awesome” itself- I’m sorry you feel that way.

        • go burn in hell you worthless cocksucker, i’ll bet you were more then happy to vote for Trump, hypocrite.

          • So you’re more than willing to give Doug a virtual bj, but me saying he’s not innocent in all this made you REEEEEE like a piglet. Good to know lol

          • Bahahaha do you know how liberal these guys are? Do you know how liberal all those guys in Hollywood that got busted are? Sorry, to shatter this illusion of yours, but not all terrible people support Trump. In fact most of the people busted openly spoke out against him or supported Hilary. Don’t bring politics into this, especially if you don’t know your facts.

      • I agree with you darkrage6.

    • I feel like sometimes people think up what seems to be a good idea…and sometimes those people are just not leaders or management types. For what seemed to them to be a company it was clearly mishandled and the sexual misconduct allegations were grossly mishandled. Instead of acting like owners or managers of a company and properly seeking out legal assistance for many of the issues (injuries on set, compensation, sexual assault, etc) they still had the mindset of “ohhhh we’re a bunch of friends hanging out, just deal with it!” and no…you can’t, not on that level, with that many people…especially the fact they didn’t try to address it at least to the victim and try to fix it somehow. I always loved watching the Nostalgia Critic and now it just doesn’t seem the same….interesting too that they released this on Vimeo and not YT…guess they realized they’d get like bombed and comments left and right.

    • TheKnifewieldingTonberry

      God do I love internet anarchy

  16. Hopefully Doug really does say something in the future b/c just ignoring this is just depressing. For crying out loud, you better fixing this behind the scenes Doug. I know you’re still making videos to try to make a revenue and hopefully keep your actors paid.

    Otherwise, this movie I haven’t seen in ages and always had fond memories of for decades. Maybe there are some rough spots, but I still like it.

    • TheKnifewieldingTonberry

      I’m afraid there is no more fixing for CA. This document set a chain of events in motion that can not be stopped anymore.
      Enjoy the shitshow while you still can. Hell, this is the first time after creating this account on I’m actually using this account, and I’m enbjoying every second of it! This is the internet equivalent of a doomsday party!

  17. Just waiting to see if Doug starts running away like mad.

  18. No matter how much anybody wants to believe, there is no actual evidence of either Doug or Rob separating from CA aside of one line on Facebook. Until someone within the Chicago group or Brad break their silence then everything is rumor. Third hand remarks are not credible, nor is Guru Larry who is just having as much fun as he can in a crap situation.

    Until it is stated otherwise there is no proof that Doug is going to do anything other than what he has been doing. Only he can prove otherwise.

    • The problem is that there’s no proof for either argument, as this may or may not be a pre-recorded review.

      If only one of the Walkers or Michaud just simply say “Doug is staying or Doug is not staying” it would really clear the cobwebs.

  19. HEH they deleted my comment… it wasn’t even that bad…



  21. Yikes a review!

    Supposedly, this is a pre-recorded review, and I hope that is the case, because otherwise this is Nero playing the fiddle while Rome burns. (Although that didn’t actually happen, but it’s still a good analogy.)

  22. The fact that this video came out “business as usual” is also “unechthsthable”. Maybe it was preset, maybe it wasn’t, but it was definitely “unechthsthable” to see this and not see any video from yourself, Rob, Mike, and even Brad to an extent.

    • There’s nothing he could really say. Most of the stuff isn’t about him, especially not the worst of it, and no matter how well he put it, it would only serve to protect his image and possibly risk his livelihood in the process, it’s not worth it.
      Also, we are not the ones that should want or need an apology, we are not the victims in any of this. It’s fine to have an opinion about what he should do, but saying anything in public will imo just seem like damage control, just like when the Hollywood actors “apologized”, it means nothing if he doesn’t talk to the people who left first.

  23. You missed the secret penis that was drawn in over tanyas mouth just after she sings near John Cleese character. Its a lot funnier now that you can’t unsee it and that you see it when it was on netflix.

  24. For a moment there I thought you were serious, you cheeky Hexagon.

  25. Jesus, almost all the comment are about this, now. I guess it’s too much to ask to just enjoy the videos in peace.

  26. Jimmy Stewart’s last words can also work for this site.

  27. Just shut up about the whole ordeal. Have you even read the document? Most of the complains were so petty they undermine the important stuff, and can be sumarized as: “This thing in our contract we signed for and agreed on? It’s unfair and we don’t like it”

    Yes, there are SOME valid points, but not 60-something pages of them, they can hardly fill 2 pages.

    • Uh, yes we read the document, that’s why a lot of us are here.

      And I have to correct you, but all the points are valid. Because unless you yourself have been berated by your boss, then you have no right to say the former producers are being petty. Especially since their boss would not even apologise.

      Although that could be you Mike Michaud under disguise, so I could be wasting my time here.

      • It’s also worth mentioning that this isn’t the first time these greivances have been aired – it’s just the first time they’ve been aired *publicly*. Before, they were told changes would be made and things would improve. That did not happen. Putting it all out there to the public was a way to hold the higher-ups’ feet to the fire. And still they refused to change things or even apologize.

    • No, because, you see, that would require them to regularly use contracts, which was one of the many many issues; no one was contracted until halfway through and only for the movies. (Or when being held ransom for their severance pay after being fired for needing to have surgery)

    • TheKnifewieldingTonberry

      You mean like letting people hunger, thirst and freeze? Yeah, totally petty.

  28. Given that Doug changed his FB employement status, does this mean Rob has as well?

  29. HereIsMy2CentsNoSpamPls

    I mean, I look forward to these Nostalgia Critic reviews, and most of his other stuff too. I’ve only recently started branching out into Tamara’s videos, and now I hear Doug is leaving? I understand wanting to get to the bottom of things, and wanting apologies… but does he really deserve this?? I’m not ready to see the end of the Nostalgia Critic, not to mention how many people (Doug, Malcolm and Tamara) I don’t want to see lose their jobs.

  30. Can we all just agree that the weird woman is Elmyra from Tiny Toons as an Adult?

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.